Unofficial Academy Awards Discussion Board

Sonic Youth wrote: Some great movies have weak 15 minute stretches. When it's the final 15 minutes, that's a problem. And that's Tar. The Asia footage was actually the least of it. Banshees is the only great movie on this list, but I could be convinced of Tar if I can find a way to believe that such a successful controlled woman can suddenly lose all impulse control.

I might address some of your issues with the film, and offer possible explanation, with what I wrote in the TAR review thread.

I calculated the results from your rankings, with a number one ranking equal to ten points, a number two ranking equal to nine points, etc. An unranked film has zero points. Here is your overall rankings with all their points following:

1: Tar - 136
2: The Banshees of Inisherin - 126
3: The Fabelmans - 97
4: Everything Everywhere All at Once - 89
5: All Quiet on the Western Front - 84
6: Triangle of Sadness - 70
7: Women Talking - 66
8: Top Gun: Maverick - 55
9: Elvis - 42
10: Avatar: The Way of Water - 34

Here's what I've got. Was hoping to get The Fabelman's in before broadcast, but it's not happening. danfrank said "I've yet to see Avatar". You can chisel that on my tombstone.

1. The Banshees of Inisherin
2. Women Talking
3. Tar (Yes, below Women Talking. I have an explanation.)
4. All Quiet on the Western Front
5. Triangle of Sadness
6. Everything Everywhere All at Once

Some great movies have weak 15 minute stretches. When it's the final 15 minutes, that's a problem. And that's Tar. The Asia footage was actually the least of it. Banshees is the only great movie on this list, but I could be convinced of Tar if I can find a way to believe that such a successful controlled woman can suddenly lose all impulse control.

In my cram session, I also watched Marcel the Shell with One Shoe, which I was prepared to hate, and Fire of Love, which I wasn't prepared to hate. It's possible Marcel may be my favorite of the year, and I couldn't get past 30 minutes of FOL.

4-7 are more or less interchangeable IMO.

1. Tár
2. Triangle of Sadness
3. The Banshees of Inisherin
4. All Quiet on the Western Front
5. Top Gun: Maverick
6. Everything Everywhere All At Once
7. The Fabelmans
8. Avatar: The Way of Water
9. Elvis
10. Women Talking

Yes, and I liked the half of Avatar: The Way of Water I saw better than the wholes of those.

dws1982 wrote:I walked out of Avatar: The Way of Water around the halfway mark. I felt like I had gotten everything I could possibly get from it and I really didn't care where the story was going and I had things to do with my day.

Did you see all of Women Talking and Elvis?

1. The Fabelmans
2. TÁR
3. The Banshees of Inisherin
4. Everything Everywhere All at Once
5. Top Gun: Maverick
6. All Quiet On the Western Front
7. Triangle of Sadness
8/unranked. Avatar: The Way of Water
9. Women Talking
10. Elvis

I walked out of Avatar: The Way of Water around the halfway mark. I felt like I had gotten everything I could possibly get from it and I really didn't care where the story was going and I had things to do with my day.

01. The Fabelmans
02. TÁR
-------
03. Everything Everywhere All at Once
04. Women Talking
05. Elvis
06. Triangle of Sadness
-------
07. All Quiet on the Western Front
08. The Banshees of Inisherin

01. Everything Everywhere All at Once
02. TÁR
03. The Banshees of Inisherin
04. Triangle of Sadness
05. The Fabelmans
06. Top Gun: Maverick
07. All Quiet on the Western Front
08. Women Talking
09. Avatar: The Way of Water
10. Elvis

1. Tár
2. The Fabelmans
3. Everything, Everywhere All at Once
4. All Quiet on the Western Front
5. The Banshees of Inisherin
6. Top Gun: Maverick
7. Elvis
8. Triangle of Sadness
9. Women Talking

1 to 5 are films I really liked. Top Gun was entertaining. Still need to see Avatar though.

I still have some watching to do, but right now, my ranking is:

1. The Banshees of Inisherin
2. Tár
3. Top Gun: Maverick
4. Everything Everywhere All at Once
5. The Fabelmans
6. Avatar: The Way of Water

And 3, 4, and 5 are pretty even in my mind.

I’ve yet to see Avatar. Here is my current ranking:

1. Tár
2. The Banshees of Inisherin
3. Women Talking
4. Everything, Everywhere All at Once
5. Triangle of Sadness
6. All Quiet on the Western Front
7. Elvis
8. The Fabelmans
9. Top Gun: Maverick

Okri wrote:Well, now I'm really curious to hear Tee's thoughts on The Fabelmans.

I'd kind of half-written something on it back in December, when I saw it, but couldn't work up the energy to polish it. Since you asked, I just posted what I'd had in the thread for the film.

1. The Banshees of Inisherin
2. The Fabelmans
3. All Quiet on the Western Front
4. Tár
5. Top Gun: Maverick
6. Avatar: The Way of Water
7. Women Talking
8. Everything, Everywhere All At Once
9. Triangle of Sadness
10. Elvis

I liked all of the films, except for Elvis. #4-8 are all pretty close for me with #2,3 a bit above and #9 a bit below.

edited to include Women Talking

I haven’t seen Women Talking. I will edit it in once I do.

1. The Banshees of Inisherin
2. Tár
3. All Quiet on the Western Front
4. Elvis
5. Top Gun: Maverick
6. Avatar: The Way of Water
7. The Fabelmans
8. Triangle of Sadness
9. Everything, Everywhere All At Once

#1-3 Outstanding
#4 Butler grounds this film
#5-6 Great fun like any summer popcorn flick
#7 Spielberg in "I want yet another Oscar" mode - hence a crashing bore
#8-9 Bordering on being absolute crap - although I'm all for a Yeoh win