Best Actress 2005

1998 through 2007

Best Actress 2005

Judi Dench - Mrs. Henderson Presents
3
7%
Felicity Huffman - Transamerica
27
60%
Keira Knightley - Pride & Prejudice
2
4%
Charlize Theron - North Country
0
No votes
Reese Witherspoon - Walk the Line
13
29%
 
Total votes: 45

Mister Tee
Tenured Laureate
Posts: 8637
Joined: Wed Jan 01, 2003 2:57 pm
Location: NYC
Contact:

Post by Mister Tee »

I agree with Magilla about the omission of Moore -- I think Prizewinner is her best post-Far fom Heaven performance. I like Allen well enough, and Kilcher; they'd have been superior to most of this drab slate. Bello, though, I think was fairly clearly supporting.

Of the selected:

Theron gives a bland, TV-movie performance in a laughably bad film. She benefitted from the "once you've won, you can be nominated anytime" precedent.

I think Dench is not only not impressive, I think her performance is fundamentally wrong-headed. For the first half, she's basically an Auntie Mame, flying past the uptight squares to get what she wants. But in the second half, her character makes no sense. There's a scene in the theatre where they're talking about wartime sacrifice, and she makes a comment so upper-class clueless it might have come out of Barbara Bush's mouth. This was the first moment in the film where I had any notion Mrs. Henderson was anything but a heroine. Soon after that, she essentially pimps one of the girls into a seemingly innocent soldier's bed -- only it turns out the soldier was no virgin, he was just looking for something on the side, and he leaves the girl knocked up (a plot development conveniently negated by a bombing raid). Yet Dench's Mrs. Henderson doesn't seem to register any of this. In her final outside-the-theatre oration, she's back to her "I just wanted our brave boys to see some titties before they died", and I fully expected she'd add "but life turned out more complicated than that". No dice; she ends up Auntie Mame again. I acknowledge much of the blame for this lies in the disappointing writing, but I don't think Dench does anything to make the character explicable. So, a big No on her.

Keira Knightley is fundamentally miscast. If Elizabeth Bennet is beautiful, Darcy would be an idiot not to snap her up. The whole point of pretty much every Austin vehicle is that the younger sister is the beauty, but that the more perceptive man will know to look beneath the surface and choose the brilliant sister. Knightley's inoffensive in the role, but she can't get past this road-block.

Felicity Huffman is respectable in an Oscar-bait role, but the script is mediocre and doesn't allow her to soar. Had she won, she'd have been one of the weaker choices of recent times (and yes, I know the surrounding context isn't exactly stellar).

I thought (along with the NY and National critics) that Witherspoon, while subsidiary to Phoenix, was clearly the best of this bunch. The movie lights up from her first scene with Phoenix at the diner. At every moment we see from Witherspoon the woman taught from childhood that pleasing an audience trumps everything -- even when the woman in the the store offers disapproval on Carter's life, Witherspoon is unfailingly polite to her. And, a really small moment: when they take the stage in the prison, Witherspoon, in background, isn't even fully in focus -- yet we see her audience-must-be-served 100-megawatt smile in the blur. This tells me she was utterly present at every moment of the film. No, she wouldn't have beat out most of my or the Academy's winners around her -- Staunton or Mirren, fuhgaeddaboutit. But in this pack, she shines brighly enough for the prize.
User avatar
Eric
Tenured
Posts: 2749
Joined: Wed Jan 01, 2003 11:18 pm
Location: Minneapolis, Minnesota
Contact:

Post by Eric »

Can't vote for any of these, sorry. Null vote.
rudeboy
Adjunct
Posts: 1323
Joined: Tue Nov 16, 2004 8:00 am
Location: Singapore

Post by rudeboy »

Awful, awful line-up. Joan Allen should have walked to a victory in such a terrible year, and there were good performances by the likes of Q'Orianka Kilcher in The New World, Maria Bello in A History of Violence, Juliette Binoche in Cache and even Naomi Watts in King Kong which were more memorable than this lot.

While Transamerica was quite watchable, I don't see anything outstanding in her rather dull lead performance. Maybe my eye was fixed on Kevin Zegers so firmly that I missed something :)

Witherspoon was lively and the best thing about Walk the Line but I'm voting for Judy Dench, who lifted a pretty flimsy film with a well judged and very likeable performance. But terrible set of nominees, really.
Big Magilla
Site Admin
Posts: 19319
Joined: Wed Jan 01, 2003 3:22 pm
Location: Jersey Shore

Best Actress 2005

Post by Big Magilla »

This year's winner was a bit of an oddity in that Reese Witherspoon's June Carter Cash in Walk the Line was decidedly a secondary character in her her husband Johnny Cash's story. Although Joaquin Phoenix as Cash was an early Oscar favorite, by year's end he was definitely an also-ran. Did they really like Witherspoon or did they want to make sure a "TV actress" didn't win?

Witherspoon's performance doesn't hold a candle to Felicity Huffman's work as the transgendered father in Transamerica, nor do any of the other nominated performances for that matter.

Keira Knightly is rather wan in Pride & Prejudice and Charlize Theron merely serviceable in North Country. Judi Dench has a few good moments in Mrs. Henderson Presents but it's far from her best performance.

Far better than any of the nominees except Huffman, Joan Plowright, not Judi Dench, gave the year's best portrayal of an old lady in the little seen Mrs. Palfrey at the Claremont. Julianne Moore, playing against type, was an ordinary/extraordinary small town wife and mother in The Prizewinner of Defiance, Ohio, another nice little film nobody went to see.

Joan Allen was almost as good as the mother in The Upside of Anger, though the film itself doesn't quite work for me.

If quality of performance were the sole criteria, it would have been Huffman, followed closely by Plowright and Moore, with Witherspoon and Dench or Allen along for the ride.




Edited By Big Magilla on 1269523548
Post Reply

Return to “The 8th Decade”